MARCH 2026

The Knights Templar of Penhill… and the Mystery of the Three Tombs

High above Wensleydale, on the wild and wind-swept slopes of Penhill, lie the haunting remains of a forgotten Templar outpost — the Preceptory of Penhill, also known as Temple Dowskar.

Today, all that survives is the broken shell of their chapel.

But within it… lies a mystery that has puzzled historians for generations.

A Hidden Templar House in the North

The Penhill preceptory was founded in the late 12th century, deep in the rugged lands of Wensleydale — far from the better-known centres of the Knights Templar.

It owed its existence to a local knight:

• William Fitz Hervey, a minor lord of Witton
• Part of a wider Yorkshire knightly family
• A donor to the Knights Templar

Through charters and estate records, we know that William granted land to the Order — land which became the foundation of Penhill.

One such charter tells us plainly:

He confirmed the gift of land “to God, the Blessed Mary, and the brothers of the Temple of Solomon… for the salvation of his soul and of all his friends, living and dead.”

This was not unusual.

For men like William, giving land to the Templars was both an act of faith… and a way to secure eternal salvation.

What the Records Reveal

The surviving Latin charters and estate surveys paint a vivid picture of Penhill’s world.

They show:

• Land donated by local knightly families
• Small scattered holdings across Yorkshire
• Tenants farming acres, tofts, and bovates
• Rents paid in coins, hens… and labour

This was not a grand fortress.

Penhill was a working religious estate — quiet, remote, and self-sufficient.

Part of a wider northern Templar network that included:

• Cowton
• Stanghow
• And links to powerful families like the Mowbrays and Percys

Even timber for building their houses was granted by powerful lords, showing the importance of the Order in the region.

The Chapel… and What Remains

Today, only the chapel survives.

Weathered stone.
Broken walls.
An altar space open to the sky.

And before that altar…

Three stone sarcophagi.

The Mystery of the Penhill Burials

This is where the story takes a darker, more intriguing turn.

Historians agree on one key point:

The Knights Templar did not bury just anyone in their chapels.

Those laid to rest before an altar were typically:

• Members of the Order
• Or elite patrons of the highest status

And yet…

At Penhill, two of the three sarcophagi are only:

1.39 metres (4 feet) in length

Far too small for an adult man.

Far too small for a Templar knight.

So… Who Lies There?

This is the mystery.

Because it raises deeply unsettling questions:

1. They cannot be Templars

The Order was composed of adult men — warrior monks.

2. They cannot be their children

Templars took vows of celibacy.

They had no legitimate heirs.

3. They are unlikely to be ordinary burials

The location — directly before the altar — is too prestigious.

4. Patrons’ children?

Possibly… but unusual.

Even wealthy patrons were rarely buried inside the chapel, and their children even less so.

Theories

No definitive answer exists.

But several theories linger:

• Children of a high-ranking patron granted exceptional burial rights
• Symbolic burials — cenotaphs rather than actual graves
• Young oblates or wards placed under Templar care
• Or something far less understood…

Because whatever the truth is…

These burials break the known rules of the Templar Order.

 A Place Where History Falls Silent

Penhill is not a grand ruin.

It does not shout its history.

It whispers it.

In fragments of Latin charters…
In scattered estate records…
In the names of forgotten men like William Fitz Hervey…

And in three silent stone coffins before an altar open to the sky.

Final Thought

The Knights Templar left behind fortresses, legends, and myths across Europe.

But here, in Wensleydale, they left something far rarer:

A mystery with no answer.

And perhaps that is what makes Penhill one of the most haunting Templar sites in England.

Learn More about the Knights Hospitallers in the UK on our main website by clicking here

Check Out out Knights Gift Store for your replica Knights Templar, Hospitaller and Order of St Lazarus Armour, weapons clothes & gifts by clicking here